Home

 Hardware

 Audio
 Controllers
 General
 Mainboards
 Modems
 Monitors
 Portables
 Printers
 Processors
 Scanners
 Storage
 Video

 Games

 Reviews
 Previews
 Cheats & Hints

 News

 Current News
 Archives

 General Info

 About Us
 Advertising
 Awards
 Contact Us
 Hot Links
 

 Downloads
 

 Message Board


 

Music selected for testing

A wide variety of music is very important, since different genres of music stress the encoding schemes in different ways. There are also sound clips which are used to test audio compression systems. We have used both these methods. While we cannot post the music we compressed on the site for download, we have posted the encoded clips and the links to obtain the originals if you wish to test them for yourself. Given below is the list of CDs we encoded...
  • • Money for Nothing - Dire Straits
  • • Rivers of Belief - Enigma
  • • Hard to swallow - Alanis Morissette
  • • Titanic (soundtrack) - James Horner
  • • The Fat of the Land - Prodigy
  • • Sixteen Stone - Bush
  • • Vs - Pearl Jam
As you can imagine, this took us quite some time to go through! Still, I wish I could have gotten the soundtrack of The Matrix. Other than that, I hope to test Eric Clapton's acoustic performances. If I do find anything varying from these results I shall post an update. These two would have stayed on my hard drive for quite awhile. ; )

The sound clips which were used are;

  • • Applaud - A bit of audience applause which compression schemes find hard to compress
  • • Castanets - A good test for temporal (time) artefacts
  • • Else - A clip of a song by Sarah Mclachlin which has both vocal and drum beats with 
  •   complex background sounds
Well, now that you've put up with the rather long (but necessary) preamble, let's get to the interesting part- the actual results of the comparison.
 
Table of contents  
Introduction TwinVQ (VQF)
Basics of audio compression Real Audio G2
Methods of comparison  Microsoft Audio 4
Software and hardware MPEG 1 layer 2 (MP2)
Selection of music for the comparison MPEG 1 layer 3 (MP3)
Index of results Conclusion
  
 
 
  
COPYRIGHT © 1998-1999 - REVIEW ZONE - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED